Accident History in Quebec: CARFAX Specifics (2025)

Introduction

In Quebec, purchasing a used vehicle requires particular vigilance regarding its accident history. With a unique reporting system managed by SAAQ and province-specific rules, understanding how accidents appear in CARFAX reports becomes crucial for any buyer.

2024 Key Figures:

• 85,000 accidents reported annually in Quebec
• 40% of used vehicles have an undisclosed accident history
• 65% of buyers are unaware of Quebec reporting specifics
• $2.3 billion annual losses due to unreported damaged vehicles

💡 Did you know? Quebec has the strictest accident reporting system in Canada, but paradoxically, the concealment rate remains high.

👉 Get a complete history report with SAAQ data

Quebec Legal Framework for Accident Reporting

SAAQ's Role

The Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec holds a unique dual role in Canada:

• Registration system regulator: Management of all registered vehicles
• Public insurer: Bodily injury coverage (no-fault regime)
• Centralized database: 8.2 million registered vehicles

This dual role allows SAAQ to have a complete view of vehicle history, from the first day of registration to deregistration.

Mandatory Reporting Thresholds

Unlike other provinces, Quebec imposes strict thresholds:

Friendly Accident Report Form

The CAI form (Constat Amiable d'Accident) represents the cornerstone of the Quebec system:

• Mandatory use since 2021 for all accidents
• Electronic transmission automatic to insurers
• Conservation in SAAQ database for 10 years
• Standardized format: Facilitates processing and reduces fraud

Tip: Even for minor accidents, filling out the CAI legally protects both parties and creates an official record.

📊 Discover how CARFAX detects unreported accidents

How CARFAX Obtains Accident Data in Quebec

Main Sources

1. Insurance companies

   • 95% of insurers share their data
   • Average transmission delay: 30-60 days

2. Certified repair shops

   • SAAQ certified repairers
   • Data on repair extent

3. Registration offices

   • Vehicle status changes
   • "Irreparable" or "Repaired" designations

Quebec-Specific Limitations

Major problem: Small accidents (< $2,000) often don't appear in CARFAX because:

• Not reported to SAAQ: Below legal threshold
• Repaired at non-partner shops: Small independent garages
• Direct payment between parties: No trace in insurance system
• Home repairs: Owner repairs themselves

Estimate: Approximately 120,000 annual accidents in Quebec escape official reporting systems.

⚠️ Warning: The absence of an accident in a CARFAX report does NOT guarantee that the vehicle has never been in an accident. A mechanical inspection remains essential.

Interpreting a Quebec CARFAX Report

Accident Severity Levels

CARFAX classifies accidents into 4 categories:

Category 1: Minor Damage

• Low-speed impact (< 15 km/h)
• Cosmetic elements only: Bumpers, fenders, headlights
• Cost: < $3,000
• Airbags: Not deployed
• Value impact: -5% to -10%
• Example: Parking lot fender bender, scrape against post

Category 2: Moderate Damage

• Slightly affected structure: Longitudinal members, front/rear crossmembers
• Airbags not deployed: Moderate impact
• Cost: $3,000 - $8,000
• Repairs: Replacement of structural panels
• Value impact: -15% to -25%
• Example: Rear collision at 30 km/h, moderate side impact

Category 3: Major Damage

• Significant structural deformation: Compromised cabin
• Airbags deployed: All or several
• Cost: $8,000 - $15,000
• Repairs: Chassis straightening, multiple replacements
• Value impact: -30% to -45%
• Risks: Long-term safety issues
• Example: Frontal collision at 50 km/h, rollover, multi-vehicle impact

Category 4: Irreparable Vehicle

• Repair cost > 70% of vehicle value
• SAAQ "Irreparable" designation: Permanent and irrevocable
• Destruction recommended: Safety compromised
• Value impact: -70% to -90%
• Circulation: Prohibited in Quebec
• Exception: Can be exported or sold for parts

🚨 Alert: Some irreparable vehicles from Quebec are illegally repaired and resold out of province. Always verify complete history!

🔍 Verify a vehicle's SAAQ status now

Decoding SAAQ Designations

"Repaired" Vehicle

• Former "irreparable" status rebuilt to standards
• Passed SAAQ inspection: Complete structural and safety verification
• Legal circulation authorized: Registration certificate issued
• Permanent mention: "Repaired" status remains for life on record
• Reduced value: Depreciation of 35% to 60% compared to market
• Insurance: Difficulties obtaining complete coverage

Important: Even "repaired," this vehicle suffered initial catastrophic damage.

"Irreparable" Vehicle

• Repair cost > 70% of pre-accident value
• Circulation prohibition: No registration possible in Quebec
• Sale for parts only: Recycling or export
• Special ownership title: "Irreparable" mention in red
• Traceability: SAAQ database publicly accessible
• Penalties: Fine of $500 to $6,000 for attempted circulation

Tip: Verify the SAAQ public registry before any used vehicle purchase.

Pitfalls to Avoid in Quebec

Unreported Accidents

Alarming statistic: 1 in 5 vehicles in Quebec has suffered an unreported accident. Main reasons:

Legal reasons:

• "Under the table" repairs: Cash payment without invoice
• Non-reporting shops: Small independent garages without CARFAX partnership
• $2,000 threshold not reached: 35% of accidents cause less damage
• DIY repairs: Owners who repair themselves

Fraudulent reasons:

• Intentional concealment: To maintain resale value
• Avoid insurance surcharge: Hide accident from insurer
• Imported vehicles: Accidents outside Quebec not reported
• Title washing: Interprovincial transfer to "clean" history

Cost for buyers: On average $6,800 loss per unreported damaged vehicle purchased.

🛡️ Protect yourself with a complete history report

Verification of Repairs

Essential Checkpoints

1. Door and panel alignment

   • Uniform spacing: 3-5 mm between all panels
   • Closing without resistance: Opening/closing test 5 times
   • Left/right symmetry: Visually compare both sides
   • Problem indicator: Uneven spaces, rubbing, noises

2. Original vs reconstruction welds

   • Regular weld points: Uniformly spaced
   • No overload: No excessive or poorly finished welds
   • Comparison: Check under hood vs non-damaged parts
   • Tools: Flashlight and inspection mirror

3. Paint code and thickness

   • Uniformity between panels: Same shine, same hue
   • Gauge-measured thickness: 100-180 microns for original paint
   • Repaint indicator: > 250 microns or significant variations
   • Critical areas: Doors, fenders, hood, roof

4. Chassis and structure inspection

   • Straight longitudinal members: No deformation or crease
   • No suspicious rust: No recent rust on exposed metal
   • VIN marking: Check consistency on chassis, door, windshield
   • Lifting points: No deformation at jack points

📋 Complete downloadable verification checklist

Impact on Value and Insurance

Depreciation by Accident Type

Insurance Consequences

Quebec Insurance Surcharge

In Quebec, insurers adjust premiums according to history:

• Minor accident: +10% to +25% on annual premium
• Moderate accident: +30% to +60% on annual premium
• Major accident: +75% to +150% on annual premium
• "Repaired" vehicle: +100% to +200% (if insurable)

Concrete example:

• Normal premium: $1,200/year
• With major accident: $2,100 to $3,000/year
• 5-year surcharge: $4,500 to $9,000

Practical Buying Guide

Mandatory Verifications

Step 1: CARFAX Report

• Verify date consistency
• Cross-reference with maintenance history
• Identify reporting gaps

Step 2: Professional Inspection

Average cost in Quebec: $150 - $300 depending on complexity

Step 3: SAAQ Verification

Free online access: SAAQ Vehicle Registry

Effective Negotiation Strategy

1. Calculate real justified depreciation

Formula: Market price × Depreciation percentage = Base reduction

2. Factor in future additional costs

Add to calculation:

• Insurance surcharge over 5 years
• Resale difficulty
• Additional maintenance costs
• Pre-purchase inspection

Frequently Asked Questions

❓ Must a seller obligatorily declare an accident?

Nuanced answer depending on seller type:

Professional seller (dealer):

• ✅ YES, absolute legal obligation according to article 147 of the Consumer Protection Act

Private seller:

• ⚠️ Moral obligation only, no strict legal framework
• Exception: If directly questioned, must answer honestly (fraud otherwise)

❓ How to detect an unreported accident?

Professional detection methods:

1. Electronic paint gauge
2. VIN verification on components
3. Lift inspection
4. Professional electronic scan
5. Revealing visual signs
6. Road test

❓ Can I cancel a sale for undeclared accident?

YES, under conditions:

• Proof of seller's knowledge
• Accident having significant impact on value
• 1-year deadline to take legal action

❓ Do dealers have access to more information?

NO for sources, YES for expertise. Dealers use same sources (CARFAX, SAAQ) but may have more expertise in data interpretation.

❓ Is an accident vehicle always a bad purchase?

NO, not necessarily - Everything depends on context. Minor cosmetic damage with proper repairs and appropriate price adjustment can be acceptable.

Conclusion: Ultimate Buyer Checklist

Before Purchase - Research and Verifications

• Complete CARFAX report
• SAAQ online status verification
• Market research
• Preliminary visual inspection
• VIN verification
• Preliminary insurance quotes

During Negotiation - Strategy

• Justified depreciation calculation
• Final insurance quotes obtained
• Future cost list
• Prepare numerical arguments
• Discussion on warranty
• Contractual clause

Finalization - Secure Transaction

• Detailed sales contract
• Secure payment
• SAAQ ownership transfer
• Active insurance
• Documentation conservation
• Time-stamped photo

---

Your vigilance is your best protection.

---

Guide updated according to 2025 Quebec regulations - Information for informational purposes. Consult legal counsel for specific situations.

Ready to buy with confidence in Quebec?
Get your complete CARFAX report with SAAQ data

Recommended related articles:

• Complete guide: Buying a used car in Quebec
• CARFAX vs AutoCheck Canada: Which to choose?
• Free VIN verification in Canada: All options
• Understanding title codes: Salvage and Rebuilt in Canada